New Reader Guide

Find your kind of trouble

A snowbound mystery, a medieval racket, a bar staffed by the dead, or a retirement home for people who used to rule the world. Start wherever the trouble sounds most inviting.

A few doors worth opening

Four worlds. A place in each.

New here? Follow your curiosity. Already know the way? Your people are waiting.

Commonly Known as the Rusty Tankard

The Rusty Tankard reading order

Follow Nyx, Rolan, Fizzle, and Bash from their first snowbound investigation. Each book has its own mystery; the party's arguments, changing names, and growing collection of grievances reward reading in order.

  1. The Succubus of the Singing Stone: a blizzard, a tavern full of suspects, and a very angry arrival.
  2. The Village That Watches: Oakhaven offers a welcome that becomes difficult to refuse.
  3. The Case of the Wrong Order: dinner at Babbington Manor turns into a locked-room investigation.
  4. The Isle of Venara: a missing noblewoman and a beauty-obsessed island at the end of a terrible sea voyage.
Do I need to read the books in order?

The individual mysteries stand alone. Starting with Book 1 gives you the party's history and the context for recurring jokes. If an island or manor-house mystery catches your eye first, you can begin there.

Where can I try the stories?

Every book page has a free first chapter to read and listen to. The first Rusty Tankard book is also available free on Barnes & Noble through its book-page link.

Are the other worlds connected to this series?

Medieval Mobsters and The Retirement Home for Evil Overlords are standalone books. Dante Raises the Dead starts a separate series. You do not need the Rusty Tankard books to enter any of them.

  1. Cover for The Succubus of the Singing Stone

    A blizzard seals the tavern. A giant kicks the door in, demanding to know who slept with his wife. The prime suspect volunteers to lead the investigation. Book 1—free on Barnes & Noble.

    Start here →
    Fantasy Mystery Book 1
  2. Cover for The Village That Watches

    A comedic fantasy mystery about a village that is impossibly welcoming—where every path is swept, every smile is warm, and every invitation to stay feels a little too sincere.

    View book →
    Fantasy Mystery Book 2
  3. Cover for The Case of the Wrong Order

    A grand dinner at Babbington Manor ends in an impossible locked-room murder. With every guest guarding a secret, Nyx and her misfit companions must untangle the evidence before the household chooses its own culprit.

    View book →
    Fantasy Mystery Book 3
  4. Cover for The Isle of Venara

    A leaking ship, a hold full of beauty supplies, and a noblewoman who stopped writing home. Nyx follows the missing letters to Venara, where looking the part seems to matter rather too much.

    View book →
    Fantasy Mystery Book 4